Smith Island Cake: The Local Legend

Eva Niessner

Maryland is well-known for a lot of savory things -- when we say Maryland food, you're probably thinking steamed crabs crusted with Old Bay, or fries eaten at the beach, or crab chips, or pit beef. But we know how to make sweet things, too! If you know Maryland desserts, you probably know the Smith Island Cake.

If you're unfamiliar, the Smith Island Cake is a dessert that features many thin layers of yellow cake with fudgy frosting in between, and a coating of chocolate on the cake's exterior. When you cut into it, you'll be rewarded with the beautiful contrasting layers of cake and frosting. (How many layers? We've seen everything from 8-10, but we'll let you decide.)

Here in Maryland, we take the cake seriously. How seriously? For the last fifteen years, it's been the official dessert of the Old Line State! And the sweet treat has a history as rich as its chocolate frosting.

Only about 200 people live on Smith Island now, but it was first settled in the 1600s, and is one of America's oldest communities that was settled by the British. That's why the locals still retain a very particular accent that sounds more English than American. Traditionally, the men of the island would go off to harvest oysters, and the women baked these cakes to hearten them during the journey. 

Of course, you don't need to an oysterman to enjoy this treat. There are many establishments on the Eastern Shore that sell these cakes, but if you're feeling ambitious, you can whip one up yourself! Keep in mind that the secret ingredients are the fudgy frosting that is sturdier than buttercream and the evaporated milk that makes it extra delicious. Here's a recipe you can try!

Feeling hungry yet? It's time to get baking -- or buying. Enjoy! 

Leave a reply

sort by date

Latest articles

Where'd That Maryland City Name Come From?

09/19/23

Where'd That Maryland City Name Come ...

  Some towns and cities have pretty obvious names. They're probably named after a geographic feature, or after the person who founded it. But what about the Maryland towns with...

read more
We Love Pumpkins! 6 Pumpkin Facts You Didn't Know

08/31/23

We Love Pumpkins! 6 Pumpkin Facts You...

    1. The largest pumpkin ever grown was over a ton in weight! That's right! An Italian man named Stefano Cutrupi grew a pumpkin in 2021 that was 2,702 pounds....

read more
COLLEGE SPORTS
Quiz: How Well Do You Know These Maryland College Teams?

08/31/23

Quiz: How Well Do You Know These Mary...

Now that football season is approaching, you're probably thinking about your alma mater's homecoming game. But how well do you actually know the teams here in Maryland? If you're an...

read more
HOROSCOPE
Madame Maryland's Horoscope: September 2023

08/31/23

Madame Maryland's Horoscope: Septembe...

Fall is in the air, Marylanders! Summer is waning, and we're finally getting some nice crisp mornings -- a sure sign that autumn will be here soon. What does the...

read more
DINOSAURS
Go Back In Time! What Was Prehistoric Maryland Like?

08/09/23

Go Back In Time! What Was Prehistoric...

You've probably seen some pictures or heard some stories about what Maryland was like before you lived here or before you were born. Maybe your grandparents showed you some snapshots...

read more
DORM HACK
10 Dorm Cooking Hacks

08/10/23

10 Dorm Cooking Hacks

  It's time to head back to school, Marylanders! If you're living in a dorm for the first (or second, or third) time, you may be wondering what you can...

read more
CALICO
5 Fun Facts About Maryland's Official Feline

08/10/23

5 Fun Facts About Maryland's Official...

  If you're a cat person, you know there's nothing cuter than a cuddly calico cat. These colorful kitties are so distinctive, and they make great pets. But here in...

read more

07/26/23

Smith Island Cake: The Local Legend

Maryland is well-known for a lot of savory things -- when we say Maryland food, you're probably thinking steamed crabs crusted with Old Bay, or fries eaten at the beach,...

read more
STATE PARKS
10 Things You Didn't Know About Maryland's State Parks

07/24/23

10 Things You Didn't Know About Maryl...

No matter what season it is here in Maryland, there's a state park waiting for you -- and Maryland has some pretty fantastic hidden gems deep in its woods! How...

read more